By the end of last week, I was getting quite good at explaining that teaching is only part of my role! It was a fairly natural thing to be asked, considering I was at the International Society for Music Education biennial conference. I was beginning to think maybe I could do with a new job title, something like “Teaching Researching Librarian”. It’s important to ‘own’ your practice, and to be able to rationalise why you do what you do. I’m beginning to feel that teaching is genuinely part of my practice, which is an interesting development, considering I had no intention of teaching when I chose instead to become a librarian several decades ago!
Monday was mostly spent at the conference. Tuesday in the Library. Wednesday a research day in St Andrews. Thursday was split between the Library and the conference, and Friday, mainly at the conference.
Scottish Music Educati0n in Recent Years
I attended Charles Byrne’s symposium, Transformations and cultural change in Scottish musical education: historical perspectives and contemporary solutions. He reminded us of the emergence of traditional music as a strong component in music education, with people like Hamish Henderson and filmmaker Alan Lomax igniting a new interest in grassroots culture, ceilidhs and other iterations of traditional music. This was mirrored by a blurring of the boundaries between formal and informal learning, and the growth of the Feis movement.
Simultaneously, there was a swing towards student-centred learning, and new thinking took centre stage: creativity, inclusion, diversity and equality. In schools, the new Standard Grade showed different emphases to earlier exams, based on all-round musicianship, multi-genre and more focus on the integrated curriculum.
There was now a move towards the professional development of traditional music tutors, and the principles of learning and teaching were summarised in a memorable acronym: PREPARE. (Participation, Resources, Ecological (music within the community), Performance, Activist, Reflective and Ethical.
Charles’ paper was subsequently responded to by Marie McCarthy, Martin [check surname], Jane Southcott and Josh Dickson. Charles’ themes were recalled and elaborated upon, particularly with regard to more emphasis on ‘meaningful engagement’ as opposed to an over-emphasis on assessment; on community and traditional music. Martin is contributing to a forthcoming Oxford Handbook of Community Music, due to be published in 2017 (edited by Lee Higgins and Brydie-Leigh Bartlett – I haven’t found reference to it on the OUP website yet). Josh spoke about a new approach to assessment in pre-honours years at RCS, and also alluded to Lori Watson’s comments about elitism, defending elite artistry in both innovation and continuation of tradition. Our traditional music students develop their own identity as a musician, as well as authenticity and integrity, in their journey as aspirational performers.
How does all this fit into my own practice? As someone who generally delivers one lecture or seminar at a time, it can be difficult to relate the bigger philosophical arguments to my own context, but it is still important to understand how what I teach sits alongside what the students are learning in other parts of their course. I’d like to know how the concept of ‘authenticity’ for today’s traditional musicians sits alongside the issues of authenticity that I research and talk about in an 18th-19th century context. Do we actually mean the same thing? Authenticity in an individual’s own performance practice, isn’t quite the same as the insistence on authenticity for individual tunes and accompaniments, but being ‘authentic’ is clearly a thread that has been interwoven through traditional music for a very long time indeed.
Symposium on Assessment
Five presentations were given. Even though the speakers often worked in the context of school rather than university, the practical suggestions meant that there would have been much food for thought for everyone. Since we have been encouraged in our own PGCert studies to consider how we assess learning to have been acquired by our students, I took copious notes. I’ll reflect on these in my next posting.