Reflecting upon Those Lessons

After the Christmas break, I thought I’d better start uploading some of the documentation for the two lessons I gave four weeks ago! Some hours later, I’ve added most of it to my 2015-16 Portfolio – I just have to do some reflection myself, now.  Transcribing student contributions and feedback forms took longer than I’d bargained for, but it was interesting to go through them with a bit of distance to add perspective.  These are some of my first impressions – I’ll try to expand upon them for my Portfolio submission.

Positives and Negatives

  • Some people disliked passing round books, but most loved this.  In all probability, the majority of students had never had such an array of early collections in their hands in the space of an hour.  I made my own specialism “cool” to one student, and it doesn’t get much better than that!
  • There was also general appreciation of the background context that I provided, and of my stories about the compilers.  One student even asked for more about classical composers’ involvement with traditional song settings.  (I had talked about Beethoven’s input into the Scots Musical Museum.)
  • The cultural context and chance to talk about this seems to have been pretty generally appreciated.
  • A few people thought there wasn’t enough discussion, but others enjoyed the discussion elements, so that seemed to have been a matter of personal taste.
  • Similarly, there were a few comments about ‘too much talking, not enough musical examples’ (I couldn’t get the internet to work on the smart-board, which was annoying but beyond my control) – but there were also positive comments about the musical examples that I did give.
  • Several people did comment about the lack of online examples – a pity.  However, I might well have other opportunities to share this element of the library provision, so all is not lost.
  • Some people wanted a wider variety of instruments to be represented – had I been able to show the website, there would have been more fiddle music than they could have got their heads around.
  • Friday mornings at 9 am aren’t popular, it seems! (No reflection on my teaching there, anyway.)
  • One student wanted more teaching about modern collections – but that wasn’t in my remit, as Lori planned to give another seminar on this herself.



2 thoughts on “Reflecting upon Those Lessons”

  1. These are good initial reflections of the lessons and provide solid ground from which to build your evaluation. Reading through your blog (both the home page and the ePortfolio 2015/16 page), I’m a little confused as to where I should be looking to find the posts that relate to your studies – an earlier post suggests that it’s the latter page, yet this post is on the home page. Given that you use your blog for a number of different purposes (which is most definitely a positive thing!), can I suggest that you make it clear what is PG Cert related and what is not – when it comes to assessing the material, it will avoid a situation where the marker ‘misses’ any relevant posts.

    It would also be great to see some comments and reflections on the online sessions as part of this module – I realise you can’t attend them in real time due to other commitments, but I’d be interested to hear your ideas having watched the recordings back.


    1. You’ll see from my subsequent post that I have been editing my categories to make the whole thing a lot simpler. However, since there were a vast number of postings, it took me many hours last weekend to rationalise as far as I have got, because each posting had to be edited on my very, painfully slow internet connection. I may do some more editing in due course, but I think I have improved the most recent ones, at any rate.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s